City votes to let St. Luke’s move forward with disputed Bannock St. design

Boise’s city council voted late Tuesday night to allow St. Luke’s Health System to move forward with its redesign of Bannock St. through its main Boise campus.  The move ends an appeal by the East End Neighborhood Association aimed at rebalancing the design towards east-west traffic.

Officials for St. Luke’s Health System said the design was the output of a long process that involved a variety of community stakeholders over more than a year.  EENA officials are frustrated city staff approved the design at the administrative level without a public input process.

“The design suggests a plaza,” EENA representative Deanna Smith said during public testimony Tuesday night. “Our position is this is no longer a plaza. East-west movement is going to increase in frequency and be a big change.”

BoiseDev Project Tracker

Presented by TOK

Smith said her group felt the design was “very close” to what it hoped to see, but it should include marked, delineated north-south crossings for pedestrians so that each traveler in a busy area would know their role.


April 2017: Cars or no? City, St. Luke’s work to find solution to Bannock design
August 2018: 
St. Luke’s, City agree on plan for Bannock St., neighborhood association appeals
August 2018: 
East End appeal on Bannock St. design upheld: St. Luke’s hospital plan can’t move forward until it’s resolved

The City of Boise required an easement down the previously-closed Bannock St. corridor as a requirement for its OK to close Jefferson St. to the north for the campus expansion. The city stressed that Bannock could be opened to all modes of transportation, including cars.

Once St. Luke’s completes construction on the Bannock St. redesign, a year-long testing phase would begin to see how the area functions. The City of Boise has final say on how the area is laid out after the test.

St. Luke’s officials have long advocated for a more plaza-focused design, dating back to a charette process in 2017 – while EENA reps have advocated for through traffic for bikes and cars to mitigate the loss of connectivity on Jefferson St.

St. Luke’s Bannock St. plaza in 2017. Photo: Don Day/BoiseDev

“St. Luke’s has shown every step of the way a sensitivity to the design criteria that the East End has proposed,” St. Luke’s attorney JoAnn Butler said during the hearing. “It’s time to allow St. Luke’s to move forward at long last.”

“I’m worried we could have some dangerous crashes in this corridor,” Smith said. “The last thing I want to do is run into someone in this corridor who is hanging on to (an) oxygen (pole).”

Mark Bowen, an engineer hired by St. Luke’s said conclusions should come after the year-long test.

“It’s going to be the testing that ultimately determines what we do,” Bowen said. “I don’t think anyone knows what is going to work best. We think coordinating this with a temporary of closure (of Jefferson St.) would be important so we could test it out.”

After debate, city council voted 3-2 to deny the appeal, allowing St. Luke’s to move forward.  Councilors Scot Ludwig, Holli Woodings and TJ Thompson voted in the majority, while council president Lauren McLean and councilor Lisa Sánchez dissented.  Elaine Clegg, who participated in the charette process and was critical of some elements St. Luke’s proposed was absent. Mayor David Bieter also made statements during the hearing and after indicating he was in favor of the modifications EENA sought – but only votes in the event of a tie.

Support our journalism: Sign up for BoiseDev FIRST and get a daily newsletter filled with news & scoops.

Don Dayhttp://linkedin.com/in/donday
Don has been covering news in Boise for 20 years. He is a National Edward R. Murrow Award winner and a Stanford University John S. Knight Fellow.

A stadium in Boise’s west downtown? A Deep Dive into the land needs for the project

BOISEDEV MEMBER PREVIEW STORY What will it take to build a stadium in Boise's West End. Aside from funding,...

Updated NW Boise subdivision looks for approval again; neighbors still concerned

The battle for the future of Northwest Boise is about to heat up again in Boise's city hall and Garden City's ACHD...