Locally owned. Supported by members.

Boise, CCDC respond to ACHD’s letter saying new urban renewal areas are illegal

Paddles Up Poke

In May, ACHD president Rebecca Arnold sent a strongly-worded letter to the Capital City Development Corporation and City of Boise. In it, she questioned a raft of new urban renewal districts in the city.

BoiseDev Project Tracker

  • CCDC Bench urban renewal district

    Click here for details, information & past stories
  • CCDC Gateway East urban renewal district

    Click here for details, information & past stories
  • CCDC Shoreline urban renewal district

    Click here for details, information & past stories

Arnold made a number of allegations – including that the new districts are gerrymandered, illegal and take funds away from ACHD.

Now, Boise’s mayor and the CCDC president are responding.

Mayor Dave Bieter replied to Arnold’s letter last month. CCDC board president Dana Zuckerman answered questions from BoiseDev late last month.

Friction between missions unneeded

“We are working to build a better Boise, and I assume everyone at ACHD is doing it for the same reason, and it’s frustrating we are always butting heads,” Zuckerman said.

- Story continues below ads -
Regence Blue Shield Idaho
Paddles Up Poke

She said CCDC decided not to take any action on the letter, beyond some internal discussion.

“It’s not shocking that that’s how some people from ACHD might feel,” she said of Arnold’s letter. “It just seems like we have some background of contentiousness – I understand it, but I don’t think it needs to continue.”

She thinks one of the central issues is her agency’s work in Downtown Boise – and ACHD’s focus on vehicle travel.

“There doesn’t need to be tension between what is good for cars and what is good for downtown – and that seems to be the tension point,” she said. “Are we in it for the good of downtown or are we in it for the trucks that are starting to get somewhere? It doesn’t have to be in conflict.”

Bieter says letter is ‘inaccurate and misleading’

Bieter used language that often matched Arnold’s in tone and strength.

“Your assertion that the districts’ boundaries as proposed are “a plain attempt to gerrymander the project area around ACHD’s primary transportation corridors” is inaccurate and misleading,” he wrote in the two-page letter.

He also picked at Arnold’s use of the word gerrymander. He defined the term as “to manipulate the boundaries of an electoral constituency so as to favor one party or class.”

“The study area boundary has absolutely nothing to do with electoral or party politics as implied by your misuse of the term gerrymander,” Bieter wrote. “Instead, the possible boundaries identified in the eligibility study naturally align with the corridors where the city (which has jurisdiction over land use decisions) anticipates commercial redevelopment.”

He said new urban renewal areas would supplement ACHD’s resources.

Bieter defended the Bench study area as supporting the goals of Boise’s land use planning to boost mixed-use projects. The mayor said major roads on the Bench “were developed primarily for automobiles (and) many lack the most basic facilities for pedestrians, cyclists, and transit users.”

Bieter also challenges Arnold’s assertion that the new urban renewal areas are not legal.

“We are certain that we are within our statutory authority and that we have complied with the law as required in the formation of the districts and the study area,” he wrote. “Having engaged with ACHD staff and leadership throughout the process for the Shoreline and Gateway districts, it is surprising to hear legal concerns expressed some six months after the formation of the districts.”

‘It doesn’t have to be that way’

Zuckerman said she wishes the agencies could find better ways to work together.

“I think people roll their eyes when they hear ACHD or roll their eyes when they hear CCDC. It doesn’t have to be that way,” she said. “We are in it for the same reasons really. Rebecca Arnold is a public servant as am I. “We’ve had unneccesary conflict with ACHD in the past and I don’t know why that continues.”

She said she is confounded that anyone can be against CCDC’s mission.

“We manage (urban renewal areas) the best we can to eliminate blight. I don’t know how anyone can be against that. It baffles me.”

Zuckerman noted one CCDC district just ended, and two more will end in the next few years. “Every tax district is getting so much money than they would have before.”

The City of Boise and Ada County Highway District will hold a joint meeting this month. Bieter suggested discussing the topic when both boards get together.

Love our stories? Get them delivered straight to your inbox each afternoon. Plus, support BoiseDev's independent journalism.

Don Day
Don is the founder and editor of BoiseDev. He is a National Edward R. Murrow Award winner and a Stanford University John S. Knight Fellow.

You asked: Why is the Egyptian Theater boarded up?

If you've driven through Downtown Boise lately you might have noticed that the doors to the Egyptian Theater are boarded up.

Sánchez proposes ordinance to separate residential & commercial rental deposits

Boise City Council is considering an ordinance to secure your rental security deposit.  City Council Member Lisa Sánchez brought...

Stalled Anthony’s restaurant restarts, announces opening date

Seafood lovers, rejoice! After putting construction on hold this Spring, construction resumes on Anthony's new restaurant in Downtown Boise.

ACHD candidates debate public transit at Boise Bicycle Project forum

The six candidates for three seats on the Ada County Highway District commission got a chance to...

Popular

Popular Idaho mountain hot springs goes up for sale

If you're someone who has thought about purchasing a hot spring, now may be the time to do it. 

Stalled Anthony’s restaurant restarts, announces opening date

Seafood lovers, rejoice! After putting construction on hold this Spring, construction resumes on Anthony's new restaurant in Downtown Boise.

Photo tour: Idaho 55 work zone down to one lane with machinery, rock in narrow canyon

Late last week, we drove through the Idaho Highway 55 canyon between Smith's Ferry and Round Valley. The Idaho Transportation recently...

Proposed tall downtown building gets reworked in face of neighbor concerns

Earlier this year, BoiseDev broke news of a new 16-story building slated for Downtown Boise. Now the project's developer...

Large student apartment project turned down after McLean breaks city council tie

Boise Mayor Lauren McLean cast the deciding vote to turn down an upscale student housing project near Boise State University.  It's the...

Saltzer Health sold again, this time to major Utah health system

Saltzer Health will soon be under new ownership. Starting Oct. 1, Saltzer Health will join Salt Lake City-based...

Related

Updated: CCDC gives first approval to new 12-story senior apartment project in Boise

Whether or not Boise gets a new main library anytime soon, a local developer is plowing ahead with a new 12-story tower...

Judge rules against Albertsons heirs in condo development suit

The battle over the height of a proposed condo project on the Boise River continues with a key legal ruling.

Portion of Boise’s 8th Street will get a makeover: bikes, sidewalks, patios

Capital City Development Corporation (CCDC) began construction this week on 8th Street between Bannock Street and State Street in Downtown Boise.

Move back to Stage 3 shows up in decreased Downtown Boise activity

Since the coronavirus pandemic began impacting Idaho, we've kept our eye on the health of several key areas. That includes Downtown Boise.
SERVPRO Certified

Latest

You asked: Why is the Egyptian Theater boarded up?

If you've driven through Downtown Boise lately you might have noticed that the doors to the Egyptian Theater are boarded up.

Les Schwab Tires, Idaho town staple, gains large new owner

The stores in Les Schwab country have a new owner. The Oregon-based tire chain went on the block last...

Large student apartment project turned down after McLean breaks city council tie

Boise Mayor Lauren McLean cast the deciding vote to turn down an upscale student housing project near Boise State University.  It's the...

Sánchez proposes ordinance to separate residential & commercial rental deposits

Boise City Council is considering an ordinance to secure your rental security deposit.  City Council Member Lisa Sánchez brought...

Tamarack Resort announces pass options and changes ahead of 2020-21 season

Tamarack Resort has announced its pass options and changes for the upcoming winter season.  Passes

Stalled Anthony’s restaurant restarts, announces opening date

Seafood lovers, rejoice! After putting construction on hold this Spring, construction resumes on Anthony's new restaurant in Downtown Boise.