Locally owned. Supported by members.

Brady: CCDC, ACHD fight a symptom of frustration over management of area’s growth

ICCU: Business Unusual

GUEST OPINION

BoiseDev Project Tracker

  • CCDC Bench urban renewal district

    Click here for details, information & past stories

The dispute which broke into the open earlier this month between the Ada County Highway District, the City of Boise and the Capital City Development Corporation should worry anyone eager to solve the region’s two great challenges, housing for all and reasonable transportation.

ACHD contends that it’s authorizing legislation takes precedence over the subsequently authorized urban renewal districts such as those CCDC wants to create on Boise’s First Bench. ACHD Chair Rebecca Arnold wrote in May that CCDC is illegally diverting funds intended exclusively for itself and that the proposed districts are “strategically locating around ACHD’s primarily transportation corridors.”

In those last four words lies the problem: “ACHD’s primary transportation corridors.” It sounds like the corridors in question—Overland, Vista, Orchard, Latah and Curtis, and money coming from them–belong in some fashion to the road builders. Thus the possessive “ACHD’s” corridors. There is no reason–and would be no money– to beautify these corridors, provide for those walking and biking or to concentrate residential and commercial development close to downtown. At least that’s what it sounds like.

Where else should districts be located than along strategically located corridors where vast millions have already been invested?

- Story continues below ads -
ICCU Idaho
Paddles Up Poke

[Brady: Growing Idaho can find ideas for education, transit from neighboring Utah]

This dispute caught my attention because of a recent experience in Northern Virginia, where I once lived before returning to Idaho decades ago. After a reception for my graduating granddaughter, I drove to dinner with old friends at a restaurant in the heart of Arlington, about eight miles. I had expected to see wholesale change, Northern Virginia having grown massively since then (with the new Amazon headquarters coming soon to the West).

I was amazed. Neighborhood after neighborhood appeared much as I remembered them—verdant and prosperous as ever, little changed. Instead, it was the major transportation corridors that had been transformed completely, particular major intersections. Inexpensive Vietnamese restaurants my family had visited had been replaced by fancy ones of all kinds and coffee shops, of course, and apartments climbed into the sky in tight concentrations. Where once there was a church now there was a high-rise but with the same church snug on the first floor.

[Voices: Citizens gather to discuss and learn about proposal for urban renewal on Boise’s Bench]

Douglas Peterson is a Boisean who recently retired after managing The Housing Company, where he helped create 1,800 affordable housing units around Idaho in ten years. Before that job, however, he held a similar housing responsibility in Arlington, Virginia. So, I asked him, what had happened back there?

Most neighborhoods did remain the same, he said. They were fully occupied and properly zoned in ways that wouldn’t likely change. Growth had been concentrated along the main transportation corridors such as Washington, Wilson and Clarendon Boulevards, and around stops on the DC Metro system, plus other bus-centered transportation hubs.

In addition to the metro, Highway 50 and Interstate 66 slice through Arlington, making comparison to Boise inexact at best. Nonetheless, in Boise’s future, the Vista and Overland intersection could be a major commercial, residential and transportation hub, same as in Arlington, which, by the way, didn’t look all that different from Boise 40 years ago. The same thing could happen at other crossroads in the proposed urban development districts. Neighborhoods in between these centers could be little different from how they appear today, as in Arlington, if they so choose.

All that’s missing in the comparison with Northern Virginia is lots of buses or other people-movers. Dense development and rapid transit are two sides of the same coin.

I have no idea whether ACHD’s leadership or Boise’s mayor is right about urban renewal law. Ada County voted to consolidate its many highway districts in 1971 and there’s no reason it shouldn’t work today. Except that the agency it authorized to build and maintain roads 48 years ago apparently sees its mission as paramount and singular when the times call for more and more cooperatively designed ways to live closer together.

ACHD has no funding for mass transportation, of course, but unless development is concentrated close to downtown pretty soon, by some means, cars on “it’s” roads will move ever more slowly. ACHD is spending massively to widen State Street but how soon will it fill up without a vigorous bus system? Housing will sprawl into the desert and soon everything between Meridian and Nampa will fill up with traffic.

ACHD calls to mind the old phrase, “To a hammer, everything looks like a nail.”
The larger shadow over this dispute is cast by the big domed structure downtown. That’s where the governor and legislature spend three months a year mostly ignoring the future of the city they dwell in and the valley bursting at the seams.

In her May letter, ACHD chair Arnold implies that CCDC was hustling up these urban renewal districts before the legislature reins it in. Legislation modifying the authority has been introduced in five straight sessions, she wrote.

She’s right. Legislators from elsewhere in the valley see a target on Boise’s back which I don’t fully understand. Isn’t the valley likely to rise or fall together? Even if one’s sole interest is creating jobs, Northern Virginia has been a job-creating monster, yet has done so by concentrating housing and moving people by means other than cars.

Three-fourths of Boise residents tell the BSU public opinion survey we’re growing too fast. That’s a sound instinct but it would be more appropriate to say we are not growing well. It will only get worse with our leading authorities at each other’s throats and those in the capital ignoring the building modern cities one smart step at a time.

Love our stories? Get them delivered straight to your inbox each afternoon. Plus, support BoiseDev's independent journalism.

Jerry Brady
While publisher of the Post Register in Idaho Falls Jerry Brady founded an economic development now called the Regional Development Alliance. He lives in Boise.

Western Aircraft to expand, double size of Boise campus

Western Aircraft, an aircraft maintenance and repair company, announced its plan to expand and double the size of its Boise campus.

New townhomes sit empty in NW Boise during housing shortage

In Northwest Boise, 22 nearly identical town homes sit empty. The brand-new Roe Street townhomes, off State Street, were approved...

First-person account: I got COVID in Boise. I’m fine, but here’s what I went through

Editor's note: A few weeks ago, we hired new reporter Autum Robertson. This spring, she contracted COVID-19. We thought her perspective...

What should the Treasure Valley’s future look like? Survey asks for input

The Community Planning Association of SW Idaho, also known as COMPASS, released a survey to see how residents envision the future. 

Popular

Sun Valley Resort releases winter plan: tweaks and adjustments

Sun Valley Resort released its plan for the upcoming winter season. As in past years, Sun Valley plans...

CenturyLink will change its name – but you may or may not see it

As the CenturyLink turns. We told you last week that the company would leave its Downtown Boise office space....

Boise-based Cradlepoint gets new owner in huge billion-dollar deal

A Boise-based company will get a new parent company, and its owners will get $1.1 billion in their pockets.

Owners apply to tear down Boise Bench office building

A 1960s office building on the Boise Bench with a unique look could soon disappear. The Clint-Graham Center at...

Meridian-area bakery/cafe locations go up for sale

Two area bakery and cafe locations just hit the market. The owners of the Great Harvest Bakery Cafe stores in Meridian...

Costco sets opening date for new Meridian store

The Treasure Valley will soon include three Costco Wholesale stores. Costco Meridian has an opening date. Just in time...

Related

Pedestrian safety upgrades planned for Boise’s Hyde Park

Ada County Highway District is hoping to make walking and biking through Hyde Park safer next year.  Next summer,...

Updated: CCDC gives first approval to new 12-story senior apartment project in Boise

Whether or not Boise gets a new main library anytime soon, a local developer is plowing ahead with a new 12-story tower...

Portion of Boise’s 8th Street will get a makeover: bikes, sidewalks, patios

Capital City Development Corporation (CCDC) began construction this week on 8th Street between Bannock Street and State Street in Downtown Boise.

Move back to Stage 3 shows up in decreased Downtown Boise activity

Since the coronavirus pandemic began impacting Idaho, we've kept our eye on the health of several key areas. That includes Downtown Boise.

Latest

Boise-based Cradlepoint gets new owner in huge billion-dollar deal

A Boise-based company will get a new parent company, and its owners will get $1.1 billion in their pockets.

Sun Valley Resort releases winter plan: tweaks and adjustments

Sun Valley Resort released its plan for the upcoming winter season. As in past years, Sun Valley plans...

Boise utility companies enact payment plans instead of utility shut-offs

Some of Boise’s major utility companies started to ease back into collections after months of holding off due to COVID-19. 

Pizza restaurant popular in North End eyes SE Boise location

A pizza restaurant in Boise's North End could open a new location. Lulu’s Pizza, which currently operates at 2594...

CenturyLink will change its name – but you may or may not see it

As the CenturyLink turns. We told you last week that the company would leave its Downtown Boise office space....

Meridian-area bakery/cafe locations go up for sale

Two area bakery and cafe locations just hit the market. The owners of the Great Harvest Bakery Cafe stores in Meridian...