Locally owned. Supported by members.

Judge rules against Albertsons heirs in condo development suit

Regence Blue Shield Idaho

The battle over the height of a proposed condo project on the Boise River continues with a key legal ruling.

BoiseDev Project Tracker

  • Trappers Island

    Click here for details, information & past stories
  • CCDC Shoreline urban renewal district

    Click here for details, information & past stories

After Boise’s Planning & Zoning Commission and Boise City Council handed down decisions they disagreed with, Albertson’s heirs Joe and Jamie Jo Scott took their disapproval to court.

The legal battle centers on Trappers Island, a proposed 304-unit condo development on the banks of the Boise River. As first reported by the Idaho Statesman, a judge ruled on the case in July and gave neither the Scott’s or developer Jayo Co. what they wanted. 

Fourth District Court Judge Patrick Miller ruled Boise City Council acted arbitrarily in its decision to grant Jayo Co. a 70-foot height exception. Instead, the earlier decision from P&Z of a 63-foot height exception will stand. 

[Albertsons’ heirs sue over condos near park & their Bench homes]

- Story continues below ads -
Regence Blue Shield Idaho
Future of Downtown

Trapper’s Island drew the ire of the Scotts for its height and location in their viewshed of the foothills from the Central Rim. They also raised concerns about the development’s proximity to Kathryn Albertson Park, which their family donated, and the Boise River Greenbelt. Those in opposition hoped for the city would require the project to stick to the 45-foot height limit allowed for the parcel. Jayo Co. requested 80 feet in its original application. 

Boise P&Z opted for a middle ground. Commissioners liked the project but felt the height should more align with the nearby 63 foot tall River’s Edge project. Commissioners also noted several times during the proceedings views are not relevant in urban planning decisions in Idaho Code. 

Appel to City Council

Both the Scotts and Jayo Co. appealed the decision to Boise City Council claiming P&Z’s decision was arbitrary. The Scotts hoped for the 45-foot height, while the developer was shooting for something higher. Boise City Council voted to increase the height limit to 70 feet to ensure the project could hold all 304 units originally proposed. 

The Scott’s sued over this decision, hoping a judge would rule the decision arbitrary and stop the project. They also alleged in their suit approving the project was in the interest of the city because of the Shoreline urban renewal district approved in 2019. 

This decision is where the city of Boise ran into legal trouble. In appeals, council members may only look at the facts studied by P&Z when deciding if it made an arbitrary and capricious decision. There can be no new fact-finding, and they cannot reverse the decision because they disagree with it. Council is merely deciding if there was an error in P&Z’s ruling. 

Miller decided the City Council acted outside its authority in the decision to change the height to 70 feet. 

“The question is whether the City Council acted within its appellate authority,” the decision said. “And even though the City Council is entitled to strong presumption, the Court finds that based on its review of the record as whole, the City Council did not have basis upon which to find P&Z’s decision was arbitrary as the term is defined within the City Code.”

The case will now go back to the City Council and it will have to affirm P&Z’s height of 63 feet. 

Urban Renewal

The decision also squarely struck down the Scotts’ assertion city council made its decision to benefit the Shoreline urban renewal district

In an initial filing, the Scotts’ attorney argued the project would be a boon to the urban renewal district at one time proposed to finance the proposed downtown Boise sports park. At the time of the initial hearings on Trapper’s Island in the fall of 2019 the developer had already announced plans to move the stadium out of the urban renewal district to another location. (The project proposal again moved to a site near Garden City).

“…The Petitioners imply that the City Council’s evaluation of the conditional use criteria might have been influenced by the goal of generating tax increment funding for the new urban renewal district,” the decision said. “On the record as Whole, the Court does not believe the record reflects the P&Z or City Council in any way considered the Developer’s representatives’ reference to tax increment revenue (Which of course is irrelevant to the issues before the City).”

Miller also disagreed with the Scotts’ arguments asserting Trapper’s Island was too large to fit on the site and is not compatible with the surrounding neighborhood.

Love our stories? Get them delivered straight to your inbox each afternoon. Plus, support BoiseDev's independent journalism.

Margaret Carmel
Margaret is a BoiseDev reporter focused on the City of Boise, housing, homelessness and growth. Contact her at margaret@boisedev.com or by phone at (757)705-8066.

You asked: Why is the Egyptian Theater boarded up?

If you've driven through Downtown Boise lately you might have noticed that the doors to the Egyptian Theater are boarded up.

Stalled Anthony’s restaurant restarts, announces opening date

Seafood lovers, rejoice! After putting construction on hold this Spring, construction resumes on Anthony's new restaurant in Downtown Boise.

Proposed tall downtown building gets reworked in face of neighbor concerns

Earlier this year, BoiseDev broke news of a new 16-story building slated for Downtown Boise. Now the project's developer...

New WinCo development in N. Meridian changes names, reworks some project elements

We told you earlier this month that the Linder Village project in North Meridian would finally start to move forward. Now,...

Popular

Les Schwab Tires, Idaho town staple, gains large new owner

The stores in Les Schwab country have a new owner. The Oregon-based tire chain went on the block last...

Large student apartment project turned down after McLean breaks city council tie

Boise Mayor Lauren McLean cast the deciding vote to turn down an upscale student housing project near Boise State University.  It's the...

You asked: Why is the Egyptian Theater boarded up?

If you've driven through Downtown Boise lately you might have noticed that the doors to the Egyptian Theater are boarded up.

Popular Idaho mountain hot springs goes up for sale

If you're someone who has thought about purchasing a hot spring, now may be the time to do it. 

Stalled Anthony’s restaurant restarts, announces opening date

Seafood lovers, rejoice! After putting construction on hold this Spring, construction resumes on Anthony's new restaurant in Downtown Boise.

Photo tour: Idaho 55 work zone down to one lane with machinery, rock in narrow canyon

Late last week, we drove through the Idaho Highway 55 canyon between Smith's Ferry and Round Valley. The Idaho Transportation recently...

Related

Albertsons’ heirs sue over condos near park & their Bench homes

Two prominent Boiseans, whose homes sit along the Boise Bench, sued the City of Boise over a proposed condo project below their...

Higher or lower: Boise city council makes decision on riverfront condos

Earlier this summer, BoiseDev told you about an abnormal situation: dueling appeals for a project. Jayo Construction...

Too high, or too low? Boise River condo project gets appeals from Albertson heirs and developer over height limits

A STORY BOISEDEV MEMBERS GOT BY EMAIL FIRST In June, the City of Boise's Planning & Zoning Commission approved...

Boise, CCDC respond to ACHD’s letter saying new urban renewal areas are illegal

In May, ACHD president Rebecca Arnold sent a strongly-worded letter to the Capital City Development Corporation and City of Boise. In it,...

Latest

Meridian Costco opening pushed back from October 15th date

Welp. That October 15th trip to the shiny new Costco Wholesale location in Meridian will have to wait. But...

Boise State Public Radio receives million-dollar gift to help support local news

Boise State Public Radio announced it recieved the largest gift in station history - $1.1 million. The money came...

Eagle arcade closes, game machines sold and moved out

After seven years in business, Grinkers Grand Palace in Eagle will no longer welcome classic game players. The 80s-style...

You asked: Why is the Egyptian Theater boarded up?

If you've driven through Downtown Boise lately you might have noticed that the doors to the Egyptian Theater are boarded up.

Les Schwab Tires, Idaho town staple, gains large new owner

The stores in Les Schwab country have a new owner. The Oregon-based tire chain went on the block last...

Large student apartment project turned down after McLean breaks city council tie

Boise Mayor Lauren McLean cast the deciding vote to turn down an upscale student housing project near Boise State University.  It's the...