Locally owned. Supported by members.

Opponents to Boise’s recycled water proposal flood public hearing

IBL Events
City Council Tuesday with Margaret Carmel

Tensions ran high at a hearing on the possibility of recycling water in Boise Tuesday night. 

During the hours-long hearing, residents from Northwest Boise came out to express skepticism and frustration at the city’s proposal for the next twenty years of water renewal services in Boise. The broad outline of the plan includes the possibility of reusing highly treated wastewater for industrial uses, recharging the aquifer or irrigation. City council could vote on it in mid-October.

The possibility of water reuse sparked significant opposition online and in Northwest Boise over concerns the wastewater will expose Boiseans to “contaminants of emerging concern.” These chemicals, which enter wastewater through the overall environment or through human waste, include prescription medications, hormones, and “forever chemicals” in the PFAS family found in household products like Teflon. 

[Deep Dive: A look at Boise’s proposal for the future of waste water]

Public Works Director Steve Burgos launched the public hearing on the plan with multiple assurances there were no specific projects up for consideration. He said city council will only approve staff to explore recycled water this fall. Individual projects would come before council later with public input. Although individual projects were not up for a vote, most residents focused their testimony on the specific proposal of piping treated wastewater down the Farmer’s Union Canal in Northwest Boise.

- Story continues below ads -
Regence Blue Shield Idaho
Boise Centre is open

Burgos said the city is equally as concerned about the contaminants as the residents. 

“We don’t have all of the science yet on these emerging constituents,” he said. “There are unanswered questions of how to regulate them, how to treat them and how to dispose of these substances. As this science evolves, we will continue to evolve our approaches.”

Neighbors not convinced

But, residents remained skeptical. In nearly all of the testimony throughout the night, residents accused the city of only looking at studies produced by the water reuse industry instead of unbiased scientific research. They expressed concern about the effluent in their yards from flood irrigation, or exposure to contaminants in the food they grow in their gardens watered from the canal. 

Richard Llewellyn, president of the Northwest Neighborhood Association and the recipient of a doctorate in biochemistry, said the city has not sought out the information it needs to make an informed decision. 

“The water reuse plan fails as written by not addressing scientific realities that are known to compromise water recycling efforts,” he said. 

The vast majority of the testimony came from concerned neighbors, but the overall plan to explore recycling water in Boise received a thumbs up from the Idaho Conservation League and Conservation Voters for Idaho. City Council Member Patrick Bageant noted during the hearing he is a board member of the Idaho Conservation League, but he did not ask the group to testify in favor.

Throughout the hearing, several council members stopped testimony from residents concerned about contaminants in their yard to try and reassure them of the city’s intentions. Bageant said he does not want to pollute anyone’s yard or garden and would not support any policies doing so. 

“I want to have an open conversation to confront the reality that we may run out of water in the future and we may be in the situation where the only drinking water we have is owned by a french company called SUEZ that sells it to us,” he said. “The last thing I am going to support is poisoning our neighborhoods.”

Strong opposition to recycled water in Farmer’s Union canal

Much of the bad blood between Northwest Boise residents and the city of Boise stems from a 2014 contract between the city of Boise and Farmer’s Union Canal Company. Under the agreement, the city of Boise would pay the ditch company $50,000 annually for 25 years so the city could have the option of sending recycled wastewater down the canal part of the year. The city’s interest in the idea stems from new environmental regulations set to take effect in 2022 requiring water entering the Boise River to be a certain temperature. 

City officials explored the concept of sending some of the water cleaned at the Lander Street Water Renewal Facility down the canal instead of into the Boise River to meet the temperature requirement without using large amounts of electricity to artificially cool the water. But, neighbors were not informed of the contract or possibility until they discovered documents related to it last summer. 

Burgos said he “owns” the city’s mistake in not communicating with residents about the possibility earlier and said the project has been paused while the contaminants are under further study. One resident who testified directly questioned Burgos about the contract and why it was still in place, despite his assurances the city is only exploring the possibility. 

“There is no obligation from the city to put the water in the canal,” Burgos said. 

Some council members skeptical of canal project

Although the Farmer’s Union Canal project was not directly up for discussion Tuesday night, several council members weighed in on the project. City Council Members Jimmy Hallyburton and TJ Thomson said they would not support the project given the strong public opposition, and the amount of unanswered scientific questions on emerging contaminants. 

“The Farmer’s Union component is a dead issue at this point,” Thomson said. “I will not be supporting that until we have broad science that supports the idea and broad public input.”

City Council Member Lisa Sanchez had a little bit of a different take. She compared the possibility of putting recycled water into the canal to the practice of Mexicans eating tacos de cabeza, which are made from the roasted meat of a cow head. Sanchez said Mexicans began roasting cow heads after they were able to get them for free from slaughterhouses. 

Sanchez said in order to address climate change the city may have to look at alternatives it might consider unsavory at first, but it could become necessary as water resources become scarce. 

“If we needed to use that canal, maybe at first we would look at it as a cow head, but we just don’t know how difficult our lives are going to get,” she said. “This year is teaching us that.”

Love our stories? Get them delivered straight to your inbox each afternoon. Plus, support BoiseDev's independent journalism.

Margaret Carmel
Margaret is a BoiseDev reporter focused on the City of Boise, housing, homelessness and growth. Contact her at margaret@boisedev.com or by phone at (757)705-8066.

City of Boise launches new team focused on climate change

Boise’s Public Works Department has a new division.  On Tuesday, Public Works Director Steve Burgos announced to City Council...

Boise looks to pathways along canals for new transportation options

Fifty years ago, the City of Boise started building the Greenbelt. Now, it is looking ahead to a new network of pathways...

After delay, nonstop flights Boise to Atlanta will take off soon

Travelers headed east will get a long-awaited nonstop flight in 2020 as planned, despite COVID-19's impact to the airline industry.

Pedestrian safety upgrades planned for Boise’s Hyde Park

Ada County Highway District is hoping to make walking and biking through Hyde Park safer next year.  Next summer,...

Popular

Boise’s Clearview Cleaning sold to larger cleaning company

Boise's Clearview Cleaning has a new owner. Kellermeyer Bergensons Services bought out the Garden City-based cleaning company earlier this...

New WinCo development in N. Meridian changes names, reworks some project elements

We told you earlier this month that the Linder Village project in North Meridian would finally start to move forward. Now,...

Poke, burritos, gems, toys and more: new stores slated for Village at Meridian

Several new stores and restaurants will open soon at the Village at Meridian. Paddles Up Poké owner Dan Landucci...

Local home prices are rising fast. Median income is not

The gap between median home prices in Ada County and median income has widened to a gulf over the past decade. 

Costco sets opening date for new Meridian store

The Treasure Valley will soon include three Costco Wholesale stores. Costco Meridian has an opening date. Just in time...

Idaho u-pick flower farm blossoms during pandemic

It's only the second season at Lovely Hollow Farm, and it's been a wild one. In 2019, flower...

Related

McLean releases economic recovery taskforce recommendations

Four months after Mayor Lauren McLean convened an Economic Recovery Taskforce to propose solutions to help the economy recover from the pandemic,...

City of Boise launches new team focused on climate change

Boise’s Public Works Department has a new division.  On Tuesday, Public Works Director Steve Burgos announced to City Council...

Boise looks to pathways along canals for new transportation options

Fifty years ago, the City of Boise started building the Greenbelt. Now, it is looking ahead to a new network of pathways...

BPD Chief: Boise needs to add 40 to 50 police officers

Boise Police Chief Ryan Lee says the city is dozens of officers behind its peer cities across the country.

Latest

Idaho u-pick flower farm blossoms during pandemic

It's only the second season at Lovely Hollow Farm, and it's been a wild one. In 2019, flower...

Local home prices are rising fast. Median income is not

The gap between median home prices in Ada County and median income has widened to a gulf over the past decade. 

Poke, burritos, gems, toys and more: new stores slated for Village at Meridian

Several new stores and restaurants will open soon at the Village at Meridian. Paddles Up Poké owner Dan Landucci...

New project in Wood River Valley to increase affordable housing options

Officials and developers broke ground on a new project aimed at helping people find affordable homes in Hailey. 

Boise’s Clearview Cleaning sold to larger cleaning company

Boise's Clearview Cleaning has a new owner. Kellermeyer Bergensons Services bought out the Garden City-based cleaning company earlier this...

McLean encourages Boiseans during COVID-19 pandemic in first State of the City speech

Instead of taking the stage in front of a crowd at Boise State University for her first State of the City speech,...